Thoughts on the current 3 girls>
Lola: Very fun, grew on me much quicker than I thought she would. The denial aspect is interesting and the teasing feels much more light hearted than I was expecting. She works way better than I thought she would most likely because it is very obvious that she isn’t that serious and genuinely cares for the MC, even while she is constantly making digs at her.
Izzy: I hope we can be the wingwoman in her story cause honestly the little bits of her and Sam pining after each other is both hilarious and heart warming. She’s cute in a ‘I must protect this small bean’ kind of way if that makes sense.
Vivi: While I share some disappointment that she loses weight at the get go, her being an Erika like character does work for me. I really hope she gets some more events to flesh out her moving in and adjusting to living with you and Lola. I also find that it would be more interesting if she only started trying to push the MC once she starts gaining weight. It feels a little more natural to have Vivi be willing to push once it is established that the other girls are letting themselves go a bit, as opposed to Vivi coming back and immediately fattening her friends. Granted I would also like that interpretation but just based off the vibes I am getting from the writing so far.
Scenes I would like to see for each of the girls:
Lola: Having her complain about being hungry on stream and the MC coming to the rescue by getting her food. Mc and her playing video games together, maybe the house has a ddr pad that Lola slowly gets worse at as she gains weight.
Izzy: More confidence building stuff. Having her get dropped off/picked up by her mother to truly show how abusive she is. Showing her drinking an insanely sugary coffee.
Vivi: Having her cook the MC and Lola meals. Having her invite the MC to go on a run or a walk. Maybe having her invite MC out to eat like Lola but have her ‘accidently’ order you more food or extra dessert. (I would find it highly amusing to have an NPC use that logic given that many games have it reversed.)
Generally speaking, more scenes with Lola and Vivi make the most sense given you all live together. Them asking if MC wants to go out for drinks. Game/Movie night. Heck even some slice of life stuff. Bickering about chores, everyone hanging out in the living room, maybe sending one of them to get food from the store so MC doesn’t have to.
Beyond all that, I did like what was here so far. Only ran into one bug with the text of Lola asking you out to eat while the MC was at stage 3 weight and asking for a full meal.
While higher weights are always the thing everyone here wants, I would like to see some more things to do gameplay loop wise. I was very surprised you couldn’t choose to play games given that is how the intro presents MC. (even just replacing the “do nothing” action with “play video game” would have worked) More events but also some activities to break up the gameplay a bit.
Kudos, great start