Having played Vintage Story for multiple hours and having killed a bear with basic Spears I have a a Bowl of Thoughts Soup.
The game isn’t that hard or tedious, but the progression is slow, but it is there and feels much better than minecraft.
Vintage Story Fixes minecraft by being what it isn’t, because Vintage Story exist I really have no issue with minecrafts direction anymore, drawing the clear line between what Survival (vintage story) and Fun for everyone (Minecraft) is.
Vintage Story is small because people do not talk about it, Minecraft only became huge because people talked about it and shared stuff online, if the people who play Vintage Story don’t share the game or make reasons for people to play the game then new people wont play the game.
How many people on WG got starbound because of Star Pounds, I would guess a few, and how many would get Vintage Story if it had a mod similar, Star Pounds is a hard mod to play, especially if you are not playing casual, but it is fun.
Vintage Story also has very customizable world settings akin to Factorio so people can make the game as easy or hard as they want.
Is it a perfect game, no, but if you liked 1.7.10 minecraft mod packs, then you would probably enjoy vintage story.
Game is cool and hopefully I will get around to or get people to help make some goofy mods for it because it would be fun.
And Vintage Story is also on Itch, so it isn’t just it’s website, but word of mouth and people helping people is what got minecraft going, and at least you don’t need to trail and error crafting recipes in Vintage Story