I have complained before on another topic about not liking all human character rosters, I wanted to make a new topic to express my opinions without loading that topic up with my rants. I probably even mentioned that I do not like humans visually. The thing is, however, that that is neither my only problem with human characters nor my biggest. Honestly, I don’t know where to begin, and this might take a while.
The games that really appeal to me are games like Shining Force or Suikoden 2 or Skylanders: Games that have their fair share of humans but also have a bunch of other different character is that you can play as. But my favorite character rosters, as you would expect, do not have humans. I don’t mind so much again having human playable characters, but I do mind the idea of catering solely to people that want human characters when your Universe can easily support non-human characters. By limiting the characters to just humans and humanoids, you are greatly limiting how a creative the characters are, and when the villains thrive on creativity, it gets kind of frustrating to see so many different creatures on the villains side but only one on the heroes side.
In addition, a lot of people genuinely do want non-human characters in video games. From my personal experience at least, people that want nonhumans are not picky. Even if it’s not going to be their favorite animal or Monster, it will still appeal to them because it’s something different from the other characters. You can still give them good personalities and backstories, and if written correctly, they can still be relatable.
That being said, I don’t necessarily need that characters that are relatable. This is the character I’m going to be watching on screen. Even in a book, I’m going to be visualizing the character. I would actually like to enjoy what I am watching or visualizing, and honestly, I think non-human characters are just more fun to watch.
It is true, however, that just because a character is not human doesn’t make them creative. I will admit that I am a little bored of all the cat and dog characters in Media. But to be honest, compare the hundreds of thousands of cats in Media to the millions upon millions of human characters, and it ends up being one of those good enough kind of things. There is just so much more you could do than just humans.
For example, I really didn’t have any interest in Final Fantasy 14 until the hrothgar. They’re basically just muscular Khajiit and the only thing really inhuman about them is their head and maybe patches of fur, but this was good enough for me. As human as all the other species looked, at least this one had a different head, and that gave it the more inhuman look that I was looking for. At the same time, it’s still a species based off a big cat.
Adding different anthropomorphic characters feels like adding completely new species. I do not treat Khajiit or argonians as the same species. However, I can treat all the human species and 3 out of 4 of the elves as the same because they do not look different enough from each other for me to treat them as a different species. The fourth elf species however, the Orcs, are in kind of a gray area for me.
—if that’s getting repetitive, scroll down—
But I think the biggest problem I have is a lot of the implications. In a lot of media, wife just feels like it’s treated as inherently evil and worthless, and the world ends up feeling like nothing more than a Sandbox for humans to do as they please. This bothers me for a few reasons.
Like, I don’t mind fighting the rynoks in Spyro 3 because I am playing as a dragon, a creature that does not exist so it has no effect on Rhinos in real life, but it becomes a lot less bearable for me when I’m killing them as the very creature that’s pushing them into Extinction in real life, which unfortunately is mostly humans. Same reason that I wouldn’t enjoy a game where you go around and kill koalas as a rabbit or a cane toad.
I know you might be tempted to say that it’s fictional and what not, but here is the problem I have. When a message is repeated over and over, for example things like furries are bad and only humans are good and nature is evil, it ends up becoming a real mindset. And oftentimes, it feels like a lot of humans will not do anything for the environment unless it benefits humans, even if it doesn’t benefit nature.
It’s also it’s not unheard of for fictional media to influence real problems. When Jaws was put into theaters, it ended up creating a spike in Shark killing. We may know a little better these days, what other animals have not been so lucky. Bats, spiders, wolves, snakes, etc. Animals that can be good and beneficial to the environment still get villainized to this day. That’s not to say that some of these animals cannot be a nuisance animals, as there are invasive snakes and what not, but still.
A friend of mine said that they are influenced by Natura who created character is it because they like those creatures. Then why are they always the bad guys? Why are all these cool creatures used almost strictly as villains? I thought I wasn’t supposed to like the villains. Surprisingly, I find myself more often than not wanting the villains to succeed at because they’re just so much cooler, more varied and interesting than the strictly human heroes.
—this is where you really need to keep an open mind—
And why do so many of these monsters and animals fight with each other? They have no qualms with each other? They will gladly fight together to fight the heroes? And yet, the heroes are only capable of fighting alongside and for creatures that look just like them? The only nonhumans that they are likely to have in their society are cats, dogs, horses, and nothing else. But more often than not they are just NPCs or Mounts. If the quote-unquote villains can get along so well and humans can only be friends with other humans, then who are the real badguys?
And I know this is going to sound drastic, but I have an incredibly low opinion on my species in general. The species that is constantly villainizing that nature and environmentalism. The creature that thinks trophy hunting African megafauna is the best way to save them. The creature that puts a light hand on bullying while putting more weight on the victims. The creature known for greed, war, environmental destruction, racism, etc. The creature that should know better than to do all this stuff. There is only so much sympathy I can have. Oh, animals are in no way perfect, but they do not have our mental ability. Even then, all species can be pretty cool in their own right.
… but so often, I just see the side of humans that only care about humans in Media. The version of humans that just go around and killing everything in their path that doesn’t look like them. The species that will likely cause more suffering if they save the day from a threat trying to keep them in check. The side of humans that live in a world made purely for humans and no other creature. The version of humans that I cannot relate to.
That is why non-human characters matter to me because they help the human characters feel more like an exception to that. It gives me a feeling that maybe humans are doing things that will benefit other creatures. And with the case of animals and anthropomorphic characters, it could actually make you realize how cool the real animals are, and that they are not monsters, but living, breathing creatures like ourselves.
But so few games or media do this. Why do I have a lot more respect for avatar The Last Airbender then I do games like Witcher 3 or Genshin Impact? That’s because avatar The Last Airbender feels like it has so much respect for life compared to other media. There are plenty of friendly non-human characters, although only two real main ones. They rarely fight or kill any of the animals… But then again they rarely kill the people either. Even the main character is a vegetarian, which I think is kind of cool.
Aside from the all-human roster, Genshin Impact gets frustrating because it doesn’t feel like it has a lot of respect for nature or non humans in general, but it often times wants to pretend it does. We have a character that cares about wolves, but the wolves are still treated as antagonists. The characters also try to save a dragon, but not before fighting the Dragon. We have these three bird gods that are not villains, but they are still kind of stuck up. We have a character with a snake, but the snake is more or less a decoration. We also have a girl with a bird familiar, but the bird familiar may not even be a living creature and could just be purely magical.
My problem with Witcher 3 is that it wants to show the evil side of humans, but doesn’t want to show the good side of anything besides humans. Most of the “monsters” that the main character saves are humanoids that might as well just be humans. He saves a few actual monsters, but all of them are still treated as evil creatures. Only Goodguys non-humans as far as I’m concerned are the trolls, and again, they’re in kind of a gray area for me. The game just feels like it had so much potential to be interesting, and it just shatters it.
And a lot of times in media, I’m actually kind of appalled by the story. Oftentimes, there will be a misanthropic villain that wants to keep humans in check, oftentimes for reasons such as they are destroying all life around them or something similar, and if the bad guys win, then that is cut down. However, if the supposed heroes win, then more often than not, they can continue to wipe out animals and destroy the environment, but hey, at least humans get away Scott free. In other words, the media wants me to side with humans just because they are humans. Honestly, misanthropic villains and animal lover villains annoy me even in video games I like, such as Pokemon sometimes.
—one more thing…—
I have complained about this to people in the past, but all I ever seem to get are excuses. “Oh, The people playing the games are human so the characters have to be human so that they are reliable and familiar.”" But that’s part of why I don’t is because I am already human and humans are the most common creatures there are. Plus, part of the reason I immersed myself into media is to get away from humans.
“But humans can be unique and diverse on their own.” I… disagree. No matter how many different backstories and personality types you give to humans, they will always still be the same species. Plus, while I value well written characters, I have seen just about everything with humans. There are so many creatures and ideas we haven’t dived into yet and I’d like to see more of them and less humans that I feel like we had exhausted. Finally, it’s hard to diversify your humans when they are all white and most or all of them have the same Anatomy.
“But it breaks the lore!” Honestly, I don’t even know how to respond to this one without coming off as a pretentious dickwad, but usually this just comes off as an excuse for bad writing. I can kind of forgive an all human roster in a game that’s supposed to be realistic and involves only human characters. In a fantasy world, however, it usually just comes off as shallow. Like, if you have anthropomorphic animals that can be just like humans, but it “breaks the lore” to have any of them be halfway decent creatures, then why do they exist with human intelligence at all?
“But it’s what people want.” This really does frustrate me because not everyone wants human characters, and when this mindset is shoved around like common knowledge, then the people that want non-human characters are often shoved aside in favor of the people that want more and more humans. And while some people are satisfied with just humans that have animal ears and Tails, for a lot of people, that isn’t good enough. I would love to see a non-human playable character in genshin Impact. I would have loved to have seen a non-human playable character in The Project X zone games. I would have loved to have seen some actual Variety in a lot of games in the modern day. It might be why I have a bigger soft spot for earthlock, an average RPG, or Bug Fables than I do for Neo TWEWY or Ni Ni Kuni 2 or most Tales Of games, Final Fantasy games, etc. Is it might be why my favorite dragon quest game in the main franchise is dragon quest 5, which admittedly is one of the more popular ones (same with Final Fantasy 7, my favorite mainline Final Fantasy), but still.
—conclusion—
I hope you took the time to read this and understand why human characters in media have become so frustrating for me. I tried to explain my reasons as calmly and rationally as possible, because I’ve had a problem with not doing so in the past. I also hope you guys don’t think differently of me it because of this. Also, I really do not want to start a fight. I just wanted to post this to let people know how I feel.