Eat The Dungeon General Discussion

Honestly I just want a shortstack in the game. though if the people who voted for other ones voted for either Dwarf or Bomblin they could eek out Clockwork.

And we still have most of a week so time will tell.

5 Likes

(agrees heartily in Furry)

5 Likes

I certainly hope so- a common cause can change the tides of oceans!

(Or something like that IDK)

1 Like

because they want the thin character to become fat. prefat is not as fun. i think thats what it is anyway.

2 Likes

Looking back at the other polls to see who’s design won… christo, Eril’s designs have won nearly every time (aside from Illusionist)… that sets a bad precedent to be honest considering if designs from one person keep winning the polls, that could lead to… Unsavory behavior.

4 Likes

That’s actually a very fair point- and I’m setting up a little survey to see if we can organize a movement to break up this pattern.

https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/W5F6SQT

And here it is! I will have to ask non-patrons to abstain from participating, sadly- I’m looking for data from who’s already voting.

1 Like

Because your idea of all of us shortstack lovers dumping our hearts into one or the other for the ā€œgreater goodā€ is a great one, but it has to be a movement we can all get behind. Considering the dwarf is the more popular of the two, I would happily sacrifice the bomblin if it means breaking the chain.

2 Likes

But of course, we’ll just have to see how it really goes.

And I have to clarify right here and now that this is not meant to be an attack on Erill or anyone who’s voting for Clockwork in anyway- I’m not gonna fault them for having personal tastes.

I just reaaaaaaaally want a goblin or even a dwarf in the roster. For spice, at least!

And I feel that something magic can happen if we try and organize and mobilize.

3 Likes

I promise you, while he’s happy his designs are winning, he actually feels a bit guilty about hogging all the spots. His words, not mine. We share designs.

Like the Hobgoblin, who I’m only posting because she was drawn after the class poll was put up so her silhouette’s missing. Yes, I like Goblinoids and there are more on the way.

5 Likes

I decided to look more closely at the votes, since I was curious if Clockwork was winning due to the poll being multivote and the Clockwork being everybody’s 2nd favorite or something like that.

So I decided to look through the voting data and see how many people only voted for one option despite the poll being multivote. The data works out like this:

  # of unique votes | % of votes for that option that are only for that option
Bomblin          13 | 40%
Wrench            2 | 16%
Clockwork        28 | 57%
Dwarf            19 | 50%
Steam Cyborg      6 | 21% 
Haunted Doll      6 | 30%
Furnace           6 | 31%

So it seems like there’s a big group of people, for whom Clockwork really is their #1 pick! I was wondering if limiting the poll to one vote per person would produce results more in line with what patrons want but I feel like this suggests the results would be the same.

11 Likes

Thank you very much! It’s good to know these kinds of things.

2 Likes

… I didn’t realize multi-voting was a thing/allowed. Huh. (That is to say, I need to go revise my vote and add in an alternate or two aside from just my top.)

1 Like

Multi-voting changes everything- instead of pooling votes, I propose we short stack voters just all vote for both dwarf and Bomblin. And feel free to ignore the survey now- no need to actually shift votes, after all.

Here’s what the survey looks like so far- mostly just Bomblin. You can still take the survey, but from here on I strongly recommend just putting votes for both.

5 Likes

I’m going to be honest, since Furnace probably isn’t going to win my second and third choice are Steam Cyborg and Clockwork. I know you’ve got a crusade going for the short characters but normal humans are pretty good :call_me_hand:. Also they both start out thin so it’ll be fun to see either of them gain.

1 Like

I think at this point it’s 50/50 people want short stack vs people want variety.

I’m the later mostly because I have no real preference here, I trust that the character is going look good no matter what one we get.

2 Likes

Clockwork is still in the lead, though Dwarf is catching up. Even though I would like Bomblin to win, fate seems not to want non-normal human designs to win.

3 Likes

I just want variety, all the current classes are human except for the illusionist.

7 Likes

Part of me wants dwarf to win to see how the exosuit is dealt with. Path of it getting overloaded and breaking down or path of more and more ridiculous upgrades?

(But yes, more variety would indeed be good.)

1 Like

While I am frustrated that neither the bomblin nor dwarf are going to win at this stage, I’m honeslty more worried about the precedent this third victory for a single type of character will set- mostly toxic behavior as more people become bitter that one guy with ā€œblandā€ designs is constantly winning over the majority, even though it’s not that person’s fault.

5 Likes

Hopefully we don’t get to the point where it’s the people that want more designs versus the people that only want humans. It’s no ones fault where their preferences lie and hopefully people will understand that. I do see how it can harm the patron bottom line given that some people sub only to vote and a group may decide that because they aren’t going to win they aren’t going to sub anymore. Again, hopefully the people supporting the game have more reasons to keep supporting it but at the end of the day the game is really good so I hope people don’t get caught up to much.

4 Likes